وحش الحارة – Neighborhood Monster

I am already aware that I am not the only one who finds the Jordan Gate buildings rather forcefully imposed on our city. Aside from the obvious technical facts such as how the hell were they licensed to be built on a spot of land that barely could manage hosting a 4 story hotel, there is also their monstrous appearance.

I was very surprised when I first saw their renderings. They look extremely out of place, a different style pasted over Amman’s canvas, a first attempt at changing the city’s visuals so severely. I mean, they’re not the first high-rise towers; from my window with my view of the 3rd Circle district, I can see several high-risers, includings the Zara Towers, Le Royal, and the Al Burj building, built back in the 70′s or 80′s . Regardless of whether I like these towers and their architecture, I still think they maintain a certain Ammanite vibe, with the stone, the curvature, and they way they melt into their surroundings. Meanwhile, for the Jordan Gate I honestly cannot see how the glass and steel monstrosities can possibly blend into the background!

Things are not made better by Amman’s natural rugged landscape, which makes these towers viewable from almost every spot in town, and as soon as you get a view of the city from the Airport Road. There are many jokes about how they are really just Amman “giving the finger” at people who come in through the city’s main entrance.

This is why I really enjoyed watching Razan Al-Khatib’s visual commentary on the Jordan Gate towers, which she labeled “وحش الحارة”, and it’s amazing how on-spot that label is.

Yamma.






  • http://shadow.manalaa.net بيسو

    أهلا بعمان في مبولة العمارة العربية الحديثة
    !!!!
    عندنا في القاهرة فيه كمية وحوش اسوء كتير من المبنى المذكور أعلاه، وتقريبا في معظم العواصم العربية فيه زيادة في عدد المبانى القبيحة ، المشكلة ببساطة أن المعمارين العرب عندهم انبهار بالعمارة الغربية وبيحولوا يقلدوها تقليد أعمى دون النظر إلى طبيعة المدينة أو تراثها
    يعنى مثلا في الدول الغربية الجو عندهم برد معظم السنة بالتالى بيعملوا المبانى من الزجاج علشان تسمح بدخول الشمس لتدفئة المكان، عندنا في دبي او القاهرة العكس تماما، الجو حر معظم السنة لكن المعمارين بيصروا على استخدام الزجاج في البناء مما يرفع من درجة الحرارة داخل المبنى وطول ما انت جو تلاقي الشمس ضاربة في وجهك

  • http://za3moot.wordpress.com/ yaseen

    Well besso, in Jordan university we had the IT building, which is an exact copy of a faculty in Germany(or so I’ve heard) in the original design it’s said that the third floor roof were made out of glass to get the most of the sun heat, in our IT building they copied that exact same idea and it turned out to be a sauna.

    I agree with roba, those buildings look like horrible.

  • http://ksharif.blogspot.com/ Khaled

    I agree, they are hideous compared to something like Le Royal which is a masterpiece of a building if you ask me.

  • Bilal – Black Jack

    I liked her work. very creative!!

  • Ahmad Al-Sholi

    Nice video, its realy funny :))))
    Their problem is the location and not the material, if they are placed in the new urban or relatively empty spaces in Amman. However, glass building materials are more efficient than the traitional stone code we have, stone mining is an environmental harm and requires more heating and cooling, glass building CAN use smart systems to do that more efficiently..
    They do like like Amman is fingering the coming, LOL..

  • Ahmad Al-Sholi

    add them to the blog banner -excuse my graphic design ignorance if its named something else-. They are part of Amman now. You have the flag, the housing bank complex, Le Royal, they are not any less :))))))

  • http://www.arabesquerhabsody.com/blog Ohoud

    pssst, there will another one in wadi saqra

    p.s: I won’t mention the name of who will do it cause it a worldwide known architect:D

  • hisham assi

    i strongly disagree robzeee 7abeeebty :) i think that the whole world is changing, and amman has to adapt one way or the other, and this is the beginning of the new ammanite sky light babe. the spot they chose is perfect when it comes to visibility, u can view the towers from almost anywhere in amman, i think they really concentrated on the visual aspect and studied it real well, but, the traffic at that area is too bad, and this wud do it worst! and finally, the glass facade is the best way not to stand in a bulky shape on the site, it gives the tower some transparency, and avoids the dabsheh look haha.. the stone on the lower sides is the best way to fit this monster “;)” with the neighboring buildings, otherwise the passersby and the buildings around would stand next to a hugely scaled tower. this way, the scale of the tower blends in with the surroundings, a buffer area to allow the people walking by to feel ok, not that if they walk next to the tower theyd feel its scale, its too huge for that but well haha.. architectural gibberish dont mind asking my what im talking about! cheers

  • Saned

    Please don’t tell me Zaha Hadid is building the one is Wadi Saqra (if that news happens to be true)

  • hisham assi

    nop, norman foster and architects are.

  • hisham assi

    nop, norman foster and miasam* architects are.

  • Faris Darwazeh

    Faris Darwazeh Says:
    December 10th, 2007 at 8:57 pm
    i must agree, but such projects are classical examples of ‘third world’ cities’ drive to modernization. Take a glance at the project planned for down town Amman and the Abdali project and i am sure more follow, and you will clearly see the contrast of the past and the future. Though i think the plans are abit too optimistic for our city, considering and in most cases, most third world urban dwellers are not per se urban dwellers as those of New Yok or London, we lack the urban cliche (speed walking, coffee and donuts on the go and most importanly atleast in the Amman case we dont walk to work).
    Back to the Neighbourhood Monster, having studied urban geography, all what can be said is debates in the academia revolve around preseving the local/original urban fabric whilst moving towards cities of the future or atleast more modern ones. I anxiously wait to see how much Amman would change over the years and i hope municipal planners act accordingly and preserve whatever heritage the city has to offer, there are plenty of examples of that not happening. In my neighbourhood, a very old house was demolished and replaced with apartments or the case with Jordan Gate being build on a park which i remember going to ever since i was a little boy or the project which took place over the summer by the 1st circle. Its truly a sad state of affair, we should look at cities say for example london or Toronto, where certain city bylaws prohibit planners or residents to damage or replace old houses, gardens, parks and in a certain house in london a stair case, due to their value, history and heritage.

  • Mohammad Azraq

    Well, yeah, I’m working there these days mandated by my company, I gree it will look out of place but is it that bad?!!I don’t know!